Baldur's Gate II: The T-Rex of RPGs

Eschalon: Book II

Publisher:Interplay Entertainment
Developer:BioWare Corp.
Release Date:2000-09-24
Genre:
  • Role-Playing
Platforms: Theme: Perspective:
  • Isometric
Buy this Game: Amazon ebay

"While <insert present day RPG> performs adequately in this regard, it still lacks the colorful, elaborately sophisticated character interactions of say, Baldur's Gate II."

Ever since the massive Baldur's Gate II was released half a decade ago, reviewers commonly levy this criticism on any RPG with a party system, and BGII remains ever the benchmark. So with RPGs now one of the most popular genres (for every three action games at this year's Tokyo Game Show, there will be two RPGs), where's the evolution? Has BGII, with its 16+ completely fleshed out recruitable NPC's - each with their own professionally voice acted and well written storyline, alignment system, and personal, optional quests - somehow been outdone by some obscure "no name" these past 5 years?

That there's a strong focus today on online multiplayer, solo party hybrid RPGs, and the conveyor belt sequels says one thing to me: a superior NPC interaction system ain't happening any time real soon.

Take for instance, the relationship between Korgan (the "evil", yet sometimes father-like dwarf) and Aerie (the young, sweet and innocent good-aligned elf). Throughout the game, Korgan made it a point to harass young Aerie at certain times in the adventure, to the point of her... well, actually issuing the party an ultimatum if you didn't get rid of him. It didn't happen right away, and she certainly worked up to her decision, however when she left the party, it hit me like a slap in the face. Poof, she was gone. She made good on her promise and, despite mine (and I'm sure many many other's) refusal to believe she wouldn't come back - after all, the game wouldn't do that, would it? - it just did not happen.

It was not only the emotional and devotional attachment to each of your characters that made this game great, but the spontaneous and inspired interactions. Every party you could throw together had characters talking, joking with, bickering or even romancing one another at every turn. And the consequences of the results were real. Party members could leave or stay, complain to you or fall in love with you (or each other, or both!), all based on your reactions. Literally it's been over 4 years after my last BGII install, and I'm in awe that I remember each of their stories as if I had just finished the game.

Yet, since Baldur's Gate II, which was based on the AD&D 2nd Edition ruleset, was given so many accolades - over 10 RPG of the Year awards through 2000 and 2001, four Game of the Year Awards, and the 4th best PC game of all time according to www.GameRankings.com (if you consider that any indication) to go along with numerous individual achievements on various levels such as (no surprise) story - there had to be more to its success formula.

As it happens, there certainly was.

In hindsight, BGII is turning out in many ways to be the evolutionary RPG equivalent to the dinosaur. It remains well known and celebrated, with our inboxes at GameBanshee still receiving hundreds of emails every month about it, yet for nearly all its major strengths, games have evolved (ostensibly at least) in a different direction. Let's take a look.

It was gigantic, at over 200 hours of gameplay, with tough completely optional battles (Kangaxx the Lich comes to mind) and an optional personal stronghold quest for each class. Nowadays, games are "long" if they last over 30. Even the RPGs. Is there a reason games have become shorter? The obvious answer would be money. Give more eye candy and reduce the length to use less assets (especially art) and shorten development time.

Perhaps an interesting question would be, "Is there any correlation between the steady decrease in the length of games and RPGs in particular, and the steady rise in the commitment to 300+ hour MMORPGs?" Interestingly, a significant percentage of your time investment in these can typically be to solo until the very high levels, especially when you start playing multiple characters. While many (even most) would say that MMOs are a completely different experience, with BGII the twisting story, continuous supply of quests with fleshed out NPC's and scripted events, and interaction between party members was almost like playing a single-player version of an MMO. So the game was huge, and represents perhaps the last of these types of monstrous single-player RPGs (except for perhaps the non party driven Elder Scrolls series). What else?

Baldur's Gate II was the last great party based game and arguably best to use the Advanced Dungeons & Dragons 2nd Edition ruleset (or any D&D ruleset for that matter), which has more recently been replaced by the 3rd and 3.5 Editions. The 2nd Edition rules were around for a very long time by the time BGII hit the shelves, and were fundamentally more esoteric. The uninitiated had to learn and understand terms like THAC0 (to hit armor class 0), Saving Throw and Initiative. The deep, party driven immersion certainly wasn't for the faint of heart with its myriad of possibilities, but to the game and manual's credit, BGII refined the system into something approachable even by more mainstream players. These days, the 3rd and later editions are based on an easier d20 system (a 20 sided dice) with much of the depth still intact.

Finally, to keep this analogy going with the dinosaurs (yes, at all costs), BGII featured an almost inexhaustible stream of impeccable 2D rendered art. With today's almost total 3D conversion, impeccable 2D rendered art is now relegated to a few franchise titles in the ever dwindling (but still breathing through a straw) Adventure genre.

From its massive length to its easy implementation of the 2nd Edition AD&D ruleset... from its nearly never ending supply of beautiful 2D artwork to its perhaps best ever character interaction in a game, Baldur's Gate II, like the dinosaur, was both the height of an era, and the end. How many other games can claim that?

Project Fantasy Unveiled - Upcoming Online Fantasy RPG
GameBanshee Site Update

As some of you may probably know, for the past several months,


Diablo IV Group Interview
Diablo IV - Open Beta Retrospective and Changes

Last month, quite a few people had a chance to experience the


Wartales Reviews
Wartales Reviews

Shiro Games' mercenary RPG Wartales left early access earlier this week, inviting


Age of Wonders 4 Developer Diary #5 - Dwarves of the Underworld
Age of Wonders 4 Developer Diary #13 - Diplomacy

Diplomacy is the main subject of the latest developer diary for Triumph


Warhammer 40,000: Rogue Trader - Secrets of the Koronus Expanse
Warhammer 40,000: Rogue Trader - Secrets of the Koronus Expanse

If you'd like to know just what kind of locations and quest


MythForce Development Update - Power Progression
MythForce Development Update - Power Progression

The latest development update for Beamdog's roguelite adventure MythForce outlines the new


Diablo IV Sorcerer Trailer and Interviews
Diablo IV Sorcerer Trailer and Interviews

Having introduced us to Diablo IV's Rogue class a couple days ago,


Master of Magic Remake - New Roadmap Revealed
Master of Magic Remake - New Roadmap Revealed

If you'd like to know what MuHa Games and their publishers over


Monomyth Update - Video Devlog 3.0: Beta Update 3
Monomyth Update - Video Devlog 3.0: Beta Update 3

Rat Tower Software's latest Kickstarter update for their dungeon-crawling RPG Monomyth showcases


Wartales Released
Wartales Released

Following just over a year of early access, Shiro Games' mercenary RPG


The Elder Scrolls Online - Arcanist Class Trailer and Necrom Prologue Quest
The Elder Scrolls Online - Arcanist Class Trailer and Necrom Prologue Quest

The Elder Scrolls Online's upcoming Necrom chapter will be going live on


The Outer Worlds: Spacer's Choice Edition Patch v1.2 Available
The Outer Worlds: Spacer's Choice Edition Patch v1.2 Available

A new patch is here for the Spacer's Choice Edition of Obsidian


Diablo IV - Early Access Beta Trailer and Guided Tour
Diablo IV - Rogue Trailer

With Diablo IV set to launch on June 6, 2023, Blizzard Entertainment


Remnant 2 - The World of Losomn Overview
Remnant 2 - The World of Losomn Overview

The latest promotional reveal for Gunfire Games' upcoming Remnant 2 is packed


New World - How PTR Changed Season 1
New World - How PTR Changed Season 1

Amazon Game Studios recently kicked off the first progression season for their


Diablo: Immortal - Heroes of Unification Update Available
Diablo: Immortal - Heroes of Unification Update Available

Blizzard Entertainment's latest content update for their mobile-focused action-RPG Diablo: Immortal kicks


Age of Wonders 4 Developer Diary #5 - Dwarves of the Underworld
Age of Wonders 4 Developer AMA

A few days back, Triumph Studios held a Reddit AMA, during which


Hellgate: London - London 2038 Development Update #38
Hellgate: London - London 2038 Development Update #38

Roughly two months after the previous update, the latest developer diary for


Warren Spector on What
Warren Spector on What "Player Powered" Means

Otherside Entertainment's upcoming immersive sim Argos: Riders on the Storm is positioned


Heroes of Might and Magic III: The Board Game - Of Managers and Designers
Heroes of Might and Magic III: The Board Game - Of Managers and Designers

Archon Studio's latest Kickstarter update for their upcoming Heroes of Might and