There's a new, negative review for ArcaniA: The Complete Tale over at RPGamer, which awards the title set in the Gothic universe a 2.0/5. The conclusions sums up the writer's feelings nicely:
ArcaniA is just an altogether frustrating experience. Its few good points fail to shine through in any way thanks to the vast number of technical and design issues. Even a fun battle system can't do much for the game other than highlight even further the wasted potential. Already facing a tough challenge to gain attention with the likes of The Witcher and The Elder Scrolls out there, ArcaniA comes off as an overly generic fantasy adventure that is so uneven and glitchy that an included expansion pack seems like a punishment rather than a bonus. Only those absolutely in need of a new RPG need apply here.