Out of Alignment
-
Category: News ArchiveHits: 1200
Anyway, the point is I always considered the D&D alignment system to be a valuable tool, while I guess some folks saw it more as a straitjacket. As a DM, I've always been pretty flexible with letting players play their own interpretation of alignment, only rarely stepping in to warn about serious deviations. And even that is more often a call for the player to roleplay an appropriate justification.
But does this apply to computer games? Particularly single-player RPGs is it of any value to designate a player-character's personality along an alignment system? Does it work at all?
I think it can. I'm just not fond of how it's usually implemented. The Bioware approach doesn't appeal to me very much, where a few actions get '˜flagged' as being automatically good or evil (or lawful vs. chaotic) and sliding your character's path in that direction. I'm not sure what's more annoying getting dinged evil for doing something that (from my vantage point) seemed perfectly justifiable if you have a slightly different interpretation of the events than the scenario designer, or NOT getting awarded appropriate (points) for going out of your way to do something heroically (or anti-heroically) good / evil. The arbitrariness of both the timing and type of reward gets frustrating.
