Originally posted by Weasel
I believe this is to teach you to work as a group. (If I understand right)
Is it fair...for a army I would say it is. Remember one day one of these 5 might have to guard/protect you or your family.
(I base this on the assumption that they have to pass. In the US, ones who can't cut it are discharged. But it takes a lot to get to this point. I don't know how it would work in your country. Maybe discharged and sent to do community service instead?
don't get me wrong, we all help each other out in there, actually we helped each other from the day one, before we even knew each others...
in example, this one guy, who didn't learn from the first time how to put clothes in the right places/make an acceptable bed, i showed him everyday couple times a day, well when ever he asked, i helped. but the fact is, he didn't learn it properly, he did improve his skills, but he wasn't able to do almost anything independently. after a week, he still hadn't learned(my opinion is he had never had to do anything by himself, someone had always done it for him, but that is just speculation(and no, i didn't do that, i instructed him how to do it by himself, but he still wasn't able to))
it was little bit frustrating to over and over taught him after the first week, but what made it hard, was that i had to do the same things myself, and i was sometimes late because i had to instruct him how to do it.
well he did leave, he had an old foot injury that came out after a small practice march(2miles) and had to leave(he was releaved until the year 2004)
the problem was that in the army, they show things once, then you practice them, after that you have to know how to do it. we do repeat the lessons couple days later, but this guy didn't learn those things for some reason, so in my opinion there was no way he would've made it even if his foot hadn't broken
i'm not the perfect soldier, i make mistakes and stuff, but you can get pretty far, by simply listening what you are taught and being thorough in your given orders.
after 3 weeks the army still sucks, but i'm still going to be there 12 months/1 year for some reason(maybe i should make an appointment on CE's couch) being a grunt sucks badly, and it pisses everyone off so badly, we've had cases of I.F.C. (identified flying chair) and banging doors etc. the weekend off(which i'm at atm) was exactly the thing that everyone needed, couple more weeks and they would've had to bring bodybags for the trainers...