Opening the Gold Box, Part 4: Pool of Radiance

The Digital Antiquarian's series of articles covering all things Gold Box history has moved on to its fourth installment, with this particular entry focusing entirely on the CRPG that originally set it down its successful, money-making course.  Not only that, but Pool of Radiance was also the first great Dungeons & Dragons-based game:

Your goals in Pool of Radiance are delivered in the form of commissions found at the city clerk's office. Several are usually available at any one time, giving the game a welcome non-linearity. As you carry out commissions, you return to the clerk to check them off your to-do list and to receive rewards in the form of experience and money. The whole process is immensely satisfying. As you build up your party, you venture further and further afield, claiming back more and more of Phlan from the monsters. This modest exercise in urban renewal feels far more rewarding than the elaborate save-the-world plots found in most CRPGs.

Another thing that happens as you complete commissions is that you gain a better and better overview of Phlan and its environs as a whole, learning how it all fits together. As usual in such old-school CRPGs as this one, each area is a fixed size, of 16 by 16 squares in this case. Yet SSI made the effort to make them fit together in logical, even intriguing ways to build a larger environment. If you can manage to get yourself in the right frame of mind, mapping really does become one of Pool of Radiance'˜s pleasures. Dorte, a spatial-puzzle-loving fan of Carcassonne and Blokus in all the ways I am not, is the cartographer when we play Gold Box games. (I'm the driver; she wants nothing to do with that quirky interface.) I caught her from time to time when we weren't playing redrawing and repositioning and even taping together her level maps to create a grand plan of Phlan: (This is fun!)

Making mapping far more fun in Pool of Radiance is the game's complete disinterest in all of the nonsense that's usually associated with it. There are no spinners or teleports or other artificial time-extenders and frustration-inducers. Unlike The Bard's Tale, Pool of Radiance has enough real content that it doesn't need that stuff. Indeed, the designers bent over backward to make mapping as painless as possible. Your grid location on the current map is usually shown right there onscreen, as is the direction you're currently facing; note the (5, 5) and the (E) respectively on the screenshot above. There's even an overhead auto-map of sorts. It's not quite ideal doors don't show up on it, nor for that matter anything else other than walls and corridors but, hey, it shows that they were trying. It's all part of a thoroughgoing theme of Pool of Radiance, that of duplicating most of the gameplay of its predecessors in the broadest strokes, but doing it all just a little bit better, a little bit smarter, and most of all with a little bit more mercy on you, the long-suffering player.

For instance, consider the case of the wandering monster. In Wizardry or The Bard's Tale, entering a new area always brings a little thrill of excitement as you get to see what types of new critters now come after you. That excitement dissipates, however, as the same handful of monsters just keep coming at you. Pretty soon you just wish you could move around and finish drawing your map without being attacked by endless hordes of the same old same old.

Pool of Radiance fixes this problem, simply and ingeniously and without requiring much technical innovation at all. When you enter a new area, you do indeed find it populated with the expected horde of wandering monsters. Once you've fought and won a certain number of combats, though, they simply stop coming. Your overarching goal being to clear the monsters out of Phlan, this makes a great deal of thematic sense for this particular game. But more importantly, it makes a lot of sense as good game design in general. Combined with lots of interesting fixed encounters, far more than the one or two typical of a Wizardry or Bard's Tale dungeon level, it keeps the game from ever descending into a dull grindfest. Just when you're starting to get tired of a stream of samey encounters, they stop. I can't overemphasize what a difference this one simple act of mercy makes for my own enjoyment of Pool of Radiance. Suddenly an entire genre of gaming that used to bore me becomes a pleasure. The older I get and the more loathe I become to waste my time on anything if I can help it, the more my first rule of game design becomes a match for my first rule of writing: don't be boring.