Delicacy of a D&D CRPG
-
Category: EditorialsHits: 4953
Article Index
Luckily, these will not be the only role-playing games that will be available this year, but they are somewhat special. They are special because they are based on the official D&D rules. Is it truly that special to produce a D&D game? In my opinion, it is. D&D is arguably one of the best-known role-playing systems on the planet. The system has millions of fans spread all over the world. Along with this vast audience, comes a large group of people that have a thorough understanding of the core rules that make up the game.
The advantage of playing a pen & paper role-playing game is that the game leaves total discretion of implementation and interpretation of the rules in the hands of the players and Dungeon Master (game leader). They decide on what features of the rules to use and how to use them. However, this decision-making for a computer D&D game is totally up to the developers of the game.
We all understand that it is much harder to develop a computer D&D game then it is to prepare for a pen & paper session. Most of us will also recognize that game designers have to work with a limited financial budget and some sort of time schedule. One important feature of both NWN and PoR:RoMD is their graphical engine. The graphical engine, which typically needs to be ready in the earlier stages of the game development, runs the risk of becoming outdated. This puts the entire game process under a certain amount of time pressure. This is something inherent to most, if not all, computer-based role-playing games.
This time pressure forces designers to make decisions on what features to implement and what features to leave out. This is the part where the underlying D&D rule set plays a critical part. Each role-playing game is basically a set of rules that determine what is possible and what isn't possible. Some of the most recognizable rules concern the options available to the player, such as: playable races, classes, skills, and spells. These represent only a limited selection of the rules involved in a game. A lot of games are based on rule sets that have nothing to do with the D&D rule set. Take for example Darklands, Daggerfall, Arcanum, Fallout, and the Might & Magic series. These games have their own rules that, while they may show some similarities to the D&D rule set, are distinctly different.
To give you an insight on the extensiveness of this D&D rule set, I will illustrate a bit of the Player's Handbook. This is the book that details the rules that players need to know to get a firm understanding of the game. The book deals with character races, classes, skills, feats, equipment, combat, adventuring, magic, and spells. These are all features that are used in a standard game. The book contains roughly 280 pages of information. Aside from the Player's Handbook, there is also a Dungeon Master Guide, which is useful for successfully leading a pen & paper session (another 260 pages).
The problem computer game designers face is that it is virtually impossible to include every possible feature of the D&D rules. Thus, we will always have a situation where hardcore D&D fans will complain that certain features of the rules have been left out. This is not the case with a game such as Arcanum for which there is no pen & paper version. In other words, fans cannot comment that the makers have left out some critical element that is featured in the pen & paper version of the game. This is something that constantly happens with D&D games, which can cause fans to be more critical of these games. If the designers aren't careful, complaints can come rather quickly when people find that, in their opinion, an important feature of the D&D rule set has been left out.
Of course, developing a D&D game also has two enormous advantages. Firstly, the Dungeons & Dragons name is widely known, helping to boost sales because of the recognizable name and in turn decreasing the possibility of a "failure." Secondly, the use of the D&D rules saves the development team a lot of work. The development teams does not need to spend any time on developing a set of rules, as these are already present in the D&D books. They only need to edit these rules in such a way that they can succesfully be incorporated into the game.
So on the one hand, the use of the D&D rule set offers considerable benefits to a computer game developer in the form of recognition and time savings. On the other hand, the use of the D&D rules comes with a few major hurdles to overcome. The designers are not the only ones that know the D&D rules, and they will most likely be criticized by fans for their implementation of those rules. Of course there is also the time frame dilemma of coming out with a game before the graphics are outdated (which is the situation Wizardry 8 could find itself in and Might & Magic VI had to overcome). There's a delicate balance a developer has to achieve when creating a D&D CRPG as opposed to one with their own ruleset (which has its own set of issues). But considering nearly 30 D&D computer games have been produced within the last 13 years, it's pretty obvious developers are willing to dive into the challenge to make a successful D&D game.
