Dungeon Siege II Review

Article Index

Eschalon: Book II

Publisher:Microsoft
Developer:Gas Powered Games
Release Date:2005-08-16
Genre:
  • Action,Role-Playing
Platforms: Theme: Perspective:
  • Third-Person
Buy this Game: Amazon ebay
The original Dungeon Siege was fun for about a day. Then the lengthy caverns, the endless routes between towns, and above all, the repetitious gameplay and linearity began to take their toll on me. At some point I stopped, and no amount of add-ons or publicity would convince me to try it again. I prefer to sleep in a bed, thank you, rather than propped up before a computer. True, your mileage may have varied, but that was my take on it.

The good news about DS2 is that Chris Taylor has taken criticisms about the original title very seriously. He's modified the game in a number of ways, and added some interesting features to this new release. The bad news, at least where I'm concerned, is that it's still not quite enough.

If you've played DS before and enjoyed it, you'll be pleased to know that the basics haven't changed. You still gather a party, whose attack abilities focus on four distinct combat sets: melee, ranged, combat magic, and nature magic. Each is improved with use, and will get a great deal of use, too, since DS is a hack-and-slash title that seldom throws one enemy at you at any time. As in both Diablo I/II and Sacred, they just crawl out of everywhere with no thought to strategy, and attempt to overwhelm you. The game lets you pause via the spacebar and issue orders to one party member, but if you switch to another, you'll quickly find your previous instructions ignored. Fortunately, the combat AI is, well, not dazzling in its brilliance, but decent enough to act intelligently. Usually.

The graphics are 3D and very attractive from a distance which is the only way you really succeed in combat, frankly but some animations, notably the basic movement of your party members, are repetitive and rather silly-looking when viewed up close. Your enemies are very varied in nature and described with vivid imagination in the manual, but in practice simply use the same basic four attack systems you already know. Kill them, and you acquire goodies: money and items, many of the latter possessing bonuses to everything from attack types to resistances. Gain experience, level up.but you know all that, right? Let's move on.

New and Improved

For starters, there's the new skills system. When one of your characters advance a level, they gain a skill point. This can be applied to any of a series of skills represented on a tree-like structure, very similar in concept to Diablo 2 (surprise, surprise). Skills add everything from the ability to shoot arrows farther to larger mana reserves. You can really tailor each character in your party through skills, producing a combat mage who excels in death magic, lightning, or fire, for instance.

There are also some skills that, acquired above certain quantities at various character levels, unlock (powers.) There are a number of these powers available to each class, and some are rather oddly distributed: why would ranged types acquire Silence, the magical ability to prevent enemies from casting spells for a time? On the other hand, many powers are just a delight to use and watch, such as Chain Lightning, Flurry, and Whirling Strike; despite the fact that the concepts were all clearly borrowed from other previously successful RPG titles. You'll find that most party members acquire several powers (and upgrade them to more powerful versions of themselves) during the game, but you can only have one available per party member from the screen interface at a time. After a power is used, it requires lengthy recharging. In the meantime you can't substitute another power that party member already has in reserve to use in the field, so don't even bother thinking that way. I'm ashamed of you.
Bob Alberti Interview - Matt Chat
Bob Alberti Interview - Matt Chat

Matt Barton is joined by Bob Alberti for the latest episode of


Path of Exile: Heist - Upcoming Updates and Fixes
Path of Exile: Heist - Upcoming Updates and Fixes

Heist, Path of Exile’s latest challenge league expansion, seems to have had


Grim Dawn Grim Misadventure #173 - Onwards into the Shattering
Grim Dawn Grim Misadventure #173 - Onwards into the Shattering

Now that the 1.1.8.0 patch for Crate Entertainment’s action-RPG Grim Dawn is


GRAVEN Revealed, Coming to Steam in 2021
GRAVEN Revealed, Coming to Steam in 2021

Developed by Slipgate Ironworks and published by 3D Realms together with 1C


Vaporum: Lockdown Reviews
Vaporum: Lockdown Reviews

Earlier this month, Fatbot Games released Vaporum: Lockdown - a prequel to their


RuneScape Coming to Steam
RuneScape Coming to Steam

Despite its humble origins as a browser game, RuneScape is now apparently


GB Feature: The Dungeon of Naheulbeuk: The Amulet of Chaos Review
GB Feature: The Dungeon of Naheulbeuk: The Amulet of Chaos Review

In our latest three-page review, we've taken a closer look at Dear


Baldur’s Gate III Race and Class Overview
Baldur’s Gate III Race and Class Overview

Larian Studios’ upcoming Baldur’s Gate III will be using the fifth edition


Fallout 76 Update - PTS News and Incoming Hotfix
Fallout 76 Update - PTS News and Incoming Hotfix

Steel Dawn, this year’s final content update for Fallout 76, will be


Ultima Online: New Legacy Announced
Ultima Online: New Legacy Announced

Ultima Online: New Legacy is a new way to play the venerable


Baldur’s Gate II Retrospective - The Anatomy of a Sequel
Baldur’s Gate II Retrospective - The Anatomy of a Sequel

With Baldur’s Gate III launching into early access on October 6th, the


Stoneshard - Way Forward Update Live
Stoneshard - Way Forward Update Live

The big Way Forward early access update for Ink Stains Games’ turn-based


Ni-Oh 2: Darkness in the Capital DLC Pack Detailed
Ni-Oh 2: Darkness in the Capital DLC Pack Detailed

Come October 15, 2020, Team Ninja’s Dark Souls-inspired samurai-themed action-RPG Ni-Oh 2


Conan Exiles: Isle of Siptah Producer’s Letter and Developer Q&A
Conan Exiles: Isle of Siptah Producer’s Letter and Developer Q&A

Last week, Funcom launched Isle of Siptah, their big Conan Exiles expansion,


Solasta: Crown of the Magister PAX Q&A Recap
Solasta: Crown of the Magister PAX Q&A Recap

Earlier this month, there was a Discord Q&A for Tactical Adventures’ upcoming