GameBanshee Forums

I've just started a little private movie club with some friends, the plan is that we'll meet once a month or once every second month, have a nice dinner and watch a movie together. It used to be a book club, but two of the participants have recently become parents, and thus don't have the energy to read books at the moment.

When we discussed what we are going to watch for the first movie meeting next Saturday, somebody suggested Molin Rouge. It turned out two people had already seen it - one absolutely loved it and thought it was wonderful, whereas the other totally hated it and thought it was the worst movie she had ever seen.

Originally posted by Mr Sleep
@Moulin Rouge, it falls into the category of the films i hate the most, namely musicals. It also features Nicole Kidman who is very uninteresting. As far as i can see it would never be worth my time so i avoided it

That was my initial response, but then I heard from somebody I think has a very good taste in film, that it was good. Perhaps I'll see it later, although this thread isn't exactly encouraging me

posted by DW
Not that I find Tom Cruise very inspiring ...I've always considered him quite vacuous....

I can only agree with you and Ysh. He seems to have developed into a slightly better actor now than he was when he was very young, but actually that doesn't say a lot since he was terrible lacking to start with.

I don't think I know anybody who is a fan of either Kidman or Cruise.

I actually saw Moulin Rouge in a preview screening, so it was pre-hype... and while I didn't vehemently dislike it, I didn't particularly like it, either, and I was very surprised at the critical acclaim it got. I actually quite like musicals o DW, I hope you're not implying bad things about Grease!! ), and I usually find Baz Luhrmann's flamboyant directorial style rather refreshing, but this one just didn't hit the mark. There were definitely good things about it - yes, the costumes were good, there were some interesting moments in the soundtrack, it was funny at times... but the whole film left me feeling rather underwhelmed. Still, I know a lot of people who love it, so I guess it's very subjective.

Originally posted by Georgi
I actually quite like musicals

Same here. I did infact enjoy dancer in the dark quite much. To bad most of the movie was filled with really bothering camera work.

@Dottie & Georgi:

Quickly, where is the garlic and silver spoons!?

Originally posted by Dottie
Same here. I did infact enjoy dancer in the dark quite much. To bad most of the movie was filled with really bothering camera work.

Oh, don't talk to me about Dancer in the Dark... I got as far as a minute into the first song, in the factory, and I couldn't stand it any longer and had to leave... (which is not generally a very responsible thing to do when you're the projectionist but it was that bad...)

Personaly I would have enjoyed a LotR musical rather much. There are many songs in the books, And it would have been fun to see something different instead of that boring action movie they put up.

Originally posted by Georgi


Oh, don't talk to me about Dancer in the Dark... I got as far as a minute into the first song, in the factory, and I couldn't stand it any longer and had to leave... (which is not generally a very responsible thing to do when you're the projectionist but it was that bad...)

The song in the factory actually made my winamp playlist.

Edit:
Besides Björk is so much cooler then Nicole Kidman.

I think the only music-oriented movie I've ever seen that I've truly enjoyed was Carlos Saura's Tango ....although that was more about dance and involved a lot of very tightly -controlled drama.......

@all, evening! well it is here anyway

Originally posted by Dottie
Personaly I would have enjoyed a LotR musical rather much. There are many songs in the books, And it would have been fun to see something different instead of that boring action movie they put up.

LOL The songs are quite cool I saw a play of The Hobbit once... I don't think it was a musical though

I don't think it was the song so much... it was just the film was so bloody depressing and dull, and then suddenly Bjork's bursting into song in the middle of the factory... I just couldn't take it

Originally posted by Dottie
Besides Björk is so much cooler then Nicole Kidman.

I love Björk's music, so I decided not to see Dancer in the dark

@DW: Evening! Or good morning, as it soon is here. (Which is a bad thing since I'm leaving for a conference 9am!)

The only musical type stuff I've seen and enjoyed, was the Dennis Potter TV-series "Pennies from heaven" and "The singing detective". They are very...eh, special.

Originally posted by Dottie
Björk is so much cooler then Nicole Kidman.

Well yes... I like her music, just not a big fan of that movie If only I hadn't seen it for free, I would have asked for my money back...

Evening DW

Originally posted by Georgi
I don't think it was the song so much... it was just the film was so bloody depressing and dull, and then suddenly Bjork's bursting into song in the middle of the factory... I just couldn't take it

I dont think it was that depressing, About everything she dreamt of did eventually come true.


*nod* @DW

Originally posted by Dottie
I dont think it was that depressing, About everything she dreamt of did eventually come true.

I didn't stay to see that much of it
I think if you're going to do a musical, then it ought to seem like a musical... Dancer in the Dark was like a serious drama, which makes it all the worse when she starts singing...

Originally posted by Georgi


I didn't stay to see that much of it
I think if you're going to do a musical, then it ought to seem like a musical... Dancer in the Dark was like a serious drama, which makes it all the worse when she starts singing...

As I interpreted the movie all the singing she did was only her dreaming at first. Then when she finally was hanged It was reality.

@Dottie you could well be right... if I actually saw the whole thing I might even agree with you... but if I find a movie so bad I don't stay until the end, I don't really give it much thought There are very few movies that I walk out of.

Originally posted by Georgi
@Dottie you could well be right... if I actually saw the whole thing I might even agree with you... but if I find a movie so bad I don't stay until the end, I don't really give it much thought There are very few movies that I walk out of.

To be honest I was about to do the same since that "artistic" camera work made me feel sick. Fortunatly I was bored atm and in the end I did like it rather much.

Originally posted by dragon wench
I am glad to hear that you don't find Nicole that exciting.... I was wondering if it was just my partner who found her uninteresting.... I guess part of my opinion has been formed by her antics in the whole Tom Cruise episode. No doubt there are two sides to it all, and personal issues we will never know about....but I found her behaviour through it all rather spiteful and vindictive....

That is part of my problem, i also think she is just well boring, she always strikes me as a pretty exterior that is belied by a rather spiteful and uncaring interior...not that i really have the necessary facts to back that up, it is just a gut feeling

Originally posted by C Elegans
@Dottie & Georgi:

Quickly, where is the garlic and silver spoons!?

Hear, hear!