The Witcher Retrospective

Eurogamer offers a retrospective on CD Projekt RED's the Witcher cRPG, discussing the amnesiac mechanic, Geralt as a PC and the stories within stories and moral greyness of the game.
The decision that stuck with me most came on my first playthrough. Having journeyed to an out-of-the-way swamp and completed several of the local quests, I had to choose one side in a conflict: the rebel force or the authoritarian soldiers. Neither side is explicitly good or evil, and you can see the point of view of both.

The rebels are made up of the non-human races (elves, dwarves and the like) and are victims of racism. They've been forced from their homes to live on the edge of poverty. With barely enough food and water for their families, they have taken to obtaining these things by force, which in some cases has led to innocent humans being caught up in the fighting between them and the authorities. You can see the persecution and, in most cases, it would be simple enough to side with them to fight against the 'evil' empire that imposes such oppression.

Except that here the empire isn't evil, and nor is it even your enemy. From the soldier's point of view, the rebels are effectively terrorists and it's not them forcing the suppression on non-humans, but society as a whole. Though the authorities are doing nothing to redress the balance, their interest is in keeping the peace and stopping any further attacks by the rebels.

So do you lead the imperial unit to the rebel camp to rout them completely, or do you lead the rebels in a pre-emptive ambush on the imperial guards camped in the forest? I felt that as a Witcher I should remain impartial and not get involved in the politics, so I continued to go about my business, determined not to help either, although it seemed that neither would attack the other until I acted and both would be stuck in their respective camps for game-time eternity. Eventually I left the swamplands, willing to leave that particular branch of the story unresolved, such was my feeling for remaining true to the neutrality of the Witcher ethos.
Cyberpunk 2077 - Night City Wire, Episode 3
Cyberpunk 2077 - Night City Wire, Episode 3

The latest episode of CD Projekt’s Cyberpunk 2077-focused Night City Wire livestream


Path of Exile: Heist Live
Path of Exile: Heist Live

Heist, this year’s third challenge league expansion for Grinding Gear Games’ free


World of Warcraft: Shadowlands - Afterlives: Revendreth Cinematic
World of Warcraft: Shadowlands - Afterlives: Revendreth Cinematic

The fourth and final Afterlives cinematic for World of Warcraft’s upcoming Shadowlands


Necromunda: Underhive Wars - Tips Trailer
Necromunda: Underhive Wars - Tips Trailer

If you’d like to know how to best tackle the plentiful tactical


Hades Leaves Early Access, Reviews
Hades Leaves Early Access, Reviews

Following roughly two years of early access, Supergiant Games’ Greek mythology-inspired roguelite


Fallout 76 - September 2020 Updates
Fallout 76 - September 2020 Updates

A few days back, Bethesda released the One Wasteland content update for


Phoenix Point: Year One Edition Announced
Phoenix Point: Year One Edition Announced

Snapshot Games will be launching the definitive Year One Edition of their


The Dungeon of Naheulbeuk: The Amulet of Chaos Released
The Dungeon of Naheulbeuk: The Amulet of Chaos Released

The Dungeon of Naheulbeuk: The Amulet of Chaos, a zany dungeon-crawling RPG


Fell Seal: Arbiter’s Mark - Anniversary Celebrations and Updates
Fell Seal: Arbiter’s Mark - Anniversary Celebrations and Updates

6 Eyes Studio launched their turn-based tactical RPG Fell Seal: Arbiter’s Mark


Guild Wars 2 - Sunqua Peak Live
Guild Wars 2 - Sunqua Peak Live

Sunqua Peak, the latest Fractal of the Mist you can tackle in


Archaelund Development Update #2
Archaelund Development Update #2

The developers over at 4 Dimension Games bring us a new update


Tainted Grail Update - Guardian Changes
Tainted Grail Update - Guardian Changes

This week’s early access update for Awaken Realms Digital’s Arthurian RPG Tainted


Vaporum: Lockdown Released
Vaporum: Lockdown Released

If you’re up for some real-time steampunk dungeon crawling and you wouldn’t


Icewind Dale: Rime of the Frostmaiden Adventure Book Released
Icewind Dale: Rime of the Frostmaiden Adventure Book Released

Revealed earlier this year during the official D&D Live event, Icewind Dale:


Neverwinter: Avernus - The Redeemed Citadel, Part 2 Live
Neverwinter: Avernus - The Redeemed Citadel, Part 2 Live

The Redeemed Citadel, Cryptic Studios and Perfect World Entertainment’s episodic campaign for