Yer question were "best
, so this be me answer.
Ye make yer pick:Variable #1:
Minsc: Silver Sword
Valygar: Celestial FuryVariable #2:
Minsc: Red Dragon Scale
Valygar: Shadow Dragon Scale
Fer the first part, Valygar be the better, fer the second one, Minsc.But
Valygar be havin' extra abilities. Fer one, with these armours picked, he'll be able to hide in shadows an' backstab, an' he has some mage spells. Also, his Dexterity will make up fer the armour loss. On the o'er hand, he be havin' less Strength, but there be plenty o' items to take care o' this.
It be yer game, ye should be able to make yer own choices, methinks.
But if ye really want me opinion, then I'd be goin' with Valygar.