Here's my breakdown of good/evil things I do.
Evil: Get Sword of Aeons. Gut Thunder on the SOA. Take Jacks Mask. Steal from homes. Use Lady Grey as a punching bag. Kill my wives that stop saying stuff like "I'm lucky to be so happy" and start saying stuff like "Hello, Husband". Get Skorms Bow.
Good: Everything else

.
Physical benefiets of Evil: Red Eyes, Fog, Jack's Mask, Sword of Aeons, Skorms Bow.
Physical benefiets of Good: Blonde Hair(!!!!), Blue Eyes, Halo, Rays of light, people falling in love with you instead of running, clapping wherever you go etc.
As you can see, I like Good much better. I do occasionally dip into the Evil side of the Alignment bar for things like SOA, Skorms Bow, and Jack's mask. But I love being good and having fans, even with Jack's Mask on. Do you know how cool it is to be a Blonde Haired Jack of Blades?? yeah, even though wearing the Mask makes you fully evi, with the right Bright equipment, and some huge donations to Avo, you can have blonde hair, halo etc. while wearing Jack's mask. Black Hair and Horns suck. Period.