You know Sib, (and Kipi too
) I think we are just going to have to agree to disagree, because I don't think either of us are going to be persuaded the other is right
The other thing is, but why even worry about games being turned into movies?
There are so many potentially interesting themes or concepts upon which to base a move... So why find inspiration in something as generic as a video game?
You'd be better off watching a bunch of campy old spaghetti westerns, which had the same kind of sharply delineated black/white, good/evil, right/wrong dichotomy.