Quote:
|
Is IWD2 better in anyone's opinion?
|
You are going to get a lot of varying opinions on this, and there is no "right" answer.
For me,
personally, I much prefer IWD over IWD2. I find the story and overall atmosphere to be far more engaging and immersive.
I have finished IWD a couple of times, and in fact I just reinstalled it again. I've never managed to complete IWD2 because it just does not seem to pull me in, and I stop caring about half way through. Also, I'm always left with the impression that the focus of IWD2 was simply to showcase the 3rd edition rules.
Of course, that is just me, and I this is a
very subjective question.
What do I like about IWD:
* While I prefer recruitable NPCs with "personalities," (like in PS:T or BG2) I do think it is fun to be able to create your own party completely because it gives you the chance to explore six different classes simultaneously. Of course, this is also a major part of IWD2 as well.
* The fact that combat often requires some thought and strategy, which counters the game's heavy emphasis on hack and slash. Again, though, you also have this in IWD2, probably to an even greater extent
* I find the music in IWD is very well done, it has a haunting quality that contributes greatly to the ambiance.
* I like the graphics and light effects as well. Even though this is an older game, I still think they have a richness to them.
* The NPCs you encounter are quite well done, IMO, and they are a very important part of conveying the story.
Is IWD one of my favourite games of all time? No, I wouldn't say that. But, I do, nonetheless, find it a very enjoyable game, especially if I'm in the mood to slice things into little bits, but I don't want something as anonymous and lacking in story as an FPS.
Quote:
|
I guess the fact that having 6 party members can be putting off. Also, the customisation of your character is really limited and annoying. Also when spending character points .. it varies. I think that's unprofessional and there should be a fixed amount
|
I suppose much of this depends on the type of games you are used to. I generally prefer D&D based games. But, they are not for everybody. If you like games with practically unlimited character customisation, and only one player character, you may be better with something like Morrowind or Gothic. Or, NWN 1 might be more to your liking; it has 3rd edition rules, and additional party members are far more optional.
It's totally up to you, obviously, but I do recommend you at least give IWD a serious try before walking away from it though.
