[Fljotsdale]

I voted Very Good. It has faults, so I couldn't vote Excellent.

The main fault is that you don't have to play the Main Quest if you don't want to; it ought to be an integral part of the game - something to build up to - not just be an optional extra.

Another fault is that there seems to be little or no play as the head of any Guilds you get to the top of. You get to be Boss, and that's it. There ought to be some sort of follow-through, however little. And it annoys me that there is no Guild interaction with other Guilds, even when one is next door to another (like Fighters and Mages Guilds). Some co-operative operations would have made the game richer, imo.