| Not all first person perspective RPGs are rubbish - tried Vampire Bloodlines? That's quite good (although extremely buggy). (Yes, I know it also has a third person perspective as well.)
I think that regardless of the engine used, it comes down to the writing within the game. Of all the games you mentioned, the strongest common thread was their writing and plot, as well as the depth of the NPCs (in most cases, anyway). F3 could be a very good game, or it could be awful, but we won't know until much further on in its development.
Cheers,
TGHO
__________________
I'm wearing Boots of Escaping! I'm wearing Boots of Escaping!
|