I think I speak for a lot of people when I say "huh?"
So... the second person is supposed to try to guess The Rule? Because if that's so what you're basically trying to get us to do is to see a pattern from only one line... and that's not possible.
Or is it someone else's turn to say "x but not y" and you'll tell him wether it follows the rule or not? And what has the validness of the statement got to do with the game (you said it was either true or false...)?
If I
am supposed to post a statement after yours that's it:
Shallow but not simple.
If not, just ignore it
