[Stilgar]

I know i'm gonna get flamed for this,
After it was sugested to me 300times by different people and after i've seen the movie, I started reading in the book.

Everyone told me how the could put their imagination into it.
How the hell can they do that,

After a few pages i was sick of it, every bush the pass by is described in every annoying and pointless detail, and so is every person.
How can there be any room left for imagination?

And then there is the singing, it's ok they like to sing, but do they have to sing a whole page long?

I stopped reading after the got to Tom Bombardil, a VERY anoying person who dous nothing but dance and sing, and brag about his pretty girlfriend. Don;t you just want to shoot the guy.

Maybe I'll try to read some more later, but this is just my first opinion.